Article
news flash
Young Sheldon’s Ming-Na Wen Plot Explains A Big Bang Theory Character Flaw
2023/08/08

ADVERTISEMENT

Sheldon was often paranoid about Penny pulling one over on him in The Big Bang Theory despite also thinking he was smarter than her, an internal contradiction that Young Sheldon offered an answer for via Ming-Na Wen's cameo. Sheldon Cooper and Penny were always bound to butt heads on The Big Bang Theory. Penny was free-spirited and fun-loving where Sheldon was uptight and cautious, and Kaley Cuoco's Big Bang Theory heroine was also deeply unpretentious where Sheldon was often insufferably smug about his superior intellect.

However, one of Sheldon's character flaws always jarred with his stated view of Penny.

ADVERTISEMENT

Throughout The Big Bang Theory (particularly in earlier seasons before he softened up somewhat), Sheldon is often suspicious of Penny and distrusts her motives. This should theoretically jar with the fact that he thinks himself far smarter than her, making his conviction that she can fool him seemingly misplaced.

However, Ming-Na Wen's Carol Lee outsmarting Sheldon in Young Sheldon season 5 explained this The Big Bang Theory character detail. Much like one Young Sheldon season 5 episode justified Sheldon's obsession with his spot by illustrating his struggles sharing a room with Missy, Carol Lee's role on the show explained why The Big Bang Theory's version of Sheldon is so oddly suspicious of Penny while still patronizing her intellect.

ADVERTISEMENT

By booby-trapping her office and catching Sheldon in the act of trying to sabotage her work, Lee proves that the character had a format experience of a glamorous, charismatic woman wooing his co-workers and tricking him into exposing his intellectual insecurities — thus making his paranoid distrust of Penny make sense.

Throughout the action of Young Sheldon's "A Free Scratcher and Feminine Wiles" (season 5, episode 14), Lee plays Sheldon's two competing colleagues off one another and ensures the pair of older scientists don't come to blows. However, this earns the ire of Young Sheldon's hero himself, prompting Sheldon to hatch a plan and get revenge on her by sabotaging Lee's work.

ADVERTISEMENT

Being a veteran in the field, Lee has encountered plenty of petty colleagues before and preempts Sheldon's attempts by booby-trapping her office and thus catching him red-handed.

The fact that Sheldon fails to acknowledge Lee's impressive intelligence in the episode and instead accuses her of using her feminine wiles to beguile his co-workers proves that the character's hubris can lead him to see even women who he doesn't respect as a threat to his work. This would explain why Sheldon is so suspicious of Penny in early The Big Bang Theory outings before eventually warming to her, as the character held onto his conviction that Lee outsmarted him rather than her simply being both his professional and personal equal in matters of both guile and scientific prowess. While many sitcom spinoffs retcon earlier character details, this Young Sheldon outing succeeded in setting up a Sheldon character flaw that can be seen throughout The Big Bang Theory's early seasons.

Young Sheldon Star Trying to Get Older Georgie Actor Onto Upcoming Spinoff
2024/06/30
'We Just Pick Right Up': Young Sheldon Star Shares Update on Georgie & Mandy Spinoff
2024/06/30
Every Young Sheldon Season, Ranked
2024/06/23
Young Sheldon Series Finale Draws Highest Viewership in Years
2024/06/13
10 Things TBBT's Sheldon Got Wrong About George Sr. From Young Sheldon
2024/06/13
Young Sheldon EP Says Georgie & Mandy Spinoff Will Have 'Its Own Identity'
2024/06/13
Young Sheldon Series Finale Review: The Two-Part Ending Closes This Chapter With a Big Bang
2024/06/13
Young Sheldon Complete Series DVD Announced Following Finale
2024/06/13
Young Sheldon Star Iain Armitage Addresses Potential Return in Spinoff Series
2024/06/13
Young Sheldon's George Cooper Actor Had a Secret Cameo in Series Finale
2024/06/13
Young Sheldon EP Reveals Deleted Funeral Moments From Final Episode
2024/06/13
Young Sheldon Series Finale, Explained
2024/06/13
'That Was Intentional': Young Sheldon EP Explains Big Change for Jim Parsons' Older Sheldon
2024/06/13
Young Sheldon EP Addresses Fan-Favorite Character’s Absence From the Finale
2024/06/13
Why Young Sheldon Is a Much Stronger Sitcom Than The Big Bang Theory
2024/06/13
Young Sheldon: 10 Best Georgie & Mandy Episodes, Ranked
2024/06/13
'It Breaks My Heart': Young Sheldon Star Feels Bad About Character's Fate
2024/06/13
Mark Hamill Shares High Praise for Young Sheldon Star Following Series Finale
2024/06/13
Young Sheldon Stars Reunite Following Lack of Closure in Series Finale
2024/06/13
The Young Sheldon Spinoff Won't Be Complete Without This One Character
2024/06/13